Hamid Ansari and Mukhtar Ansari are two well-known figures in Indian society, albeit for different reasons. While Hamid Ansari is recognized for his contributions to diplomacy and politics, Mukhtar Ansari is infamous for his criminal background and political career. This article delves into their contributions, controversies, and overall influence.
Hamid Ansari: A Diplomat and Statesman
Hamid Ansari served as the Vice President of India from 2007 to 2017. Before that, he held significant positions such as India’s Ambassador to multiple countries, the Vice Chancellor of Aligarh Muslim University, and the Chairman of the National Commission for Minorities. His tenure as Vice President was marked by his advocacy for minority rights, secularism, and diplomatic efforts to strengthen India’s global presence.
However, his statements and views have often sparked controversies. One of the most debated moments came when he stated that Muslims in India felt insecure and restless. This remark drew criticism from various political circles, with many questioning whether such a statement was justified given his own illustrious career in the Indian government.
Exclusive Interview with Hamid Ansari
In an exclusive interview, Hamid Ansari was asked about his statements regarding the insecurity felt by Muslims in India. Here’s an excerpt from their conversation:
The Heated Exchange
Hamid Ansari: Why did you come?
Journalist: To ask you a question?
Journalist: Because you have been the Vice President, and I have come to ask questions.
Hamid Ansari: When did I call you here? Did I send you an invitation?
Journalist: Sir, why are you getting angry with the questions?
Hamid Ansari: I am not angry with the questions. I am angry with your mentality.
Journalist: Sir, if you allow me, I would like to ask you something.
Hamid Ansari: Go ahead.
Journalist: You once said that Muslims in India feel a sense of restlessness and insecurity.
Hamid Ansari: So, what is strange about that statement?
Journalist: Sir, can you give one reason why you feel that way? Has this country ever judged you by your religion? You were the Vice President of India for ten years, the Vice Chancellor of Aligarh Muslim University, the Chairman of the National Minority Commission, a permanent representative, and an ambassador to several countries. You held many prestigious positions, but on your last day in office, you said that Muslims feel insecure.
Hamid Ansari: Because they are.
Journalist: Sir, it is true that you are a Muslim, but can you explain why you feel this way? Do you think issues like triple talaq contribute to this feeling?
Hamid Ansari: No, it is not about that. It has because of the basis of their merit.
Journalist: Then can you give us a concrete reason?
Hamid Ansari: I cannot give you a reason.
Journalist: This is because there is no reason.
This interview reflects the intense scrutiny and debate surrounding Hamid Ansari’s statements, with critics arguing that his views are more reflective of perception rather than reality.
Mukhtar Ansari: A Politician with a Criminal Past
Mukhtar Ansari is a name synonymous with crime and politics in Uttar Pradesh. A former Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA), he has been involved in numerous criminal cases, including murder, extortion, and land grabbing. Despite his criminal background, he maintained strong political influence for decades, winning elections multiple times and building a reputation as a strongman.
However, his reign saw a major setback when Yogi Adityanath became the Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh. Determined to crack down on organized crime, the Uttar Pradesh government initiated stringent actions against criminals, including Mukhtar Ansari. The legal battle to bring him back from Punjab’s Ropar Jail to Uttar Pradesh escalated to the Supreme Court, highlighting his deep entanglement in legal troubles.
Hamid Ansari and Mukhtar Ansari: The Connection
One of the lesser-known aspects of Mukhtar Ansari’s life is his claimed connection to Hamid Ansari. During his legal battle, Mukhtar Ansari filed an affidavit in the Supreme Court stating that he belonged to a prestigious family that had made significant contributions to India’s independence. He mentioned that former Vice President Hamid Ansari also hails from the same family. Additionally, it is said that former Governor Tula Ansari and former Justice of the Allahabad High Court, Asif Ansari, are also members of this lineage.
While there is a historical family connection, their individual paths could not be more different. Hamid Ansari has built his reputation as a scholar, diplomat, and advocate for constitutional values, whereas Mukhtar Ansari’s legacy is marred by crime and controversy.
Conclusion
Hamid Ansari and Mukhtar Ansari represent two starkly different sides of Indian public life. Hamid Ansari’s career is marked by intellectualism, diplomacy, and governance, while Mukhtar Ansari’s journey is one of crime, power, and political survival. Their connection, though rooted in history, does not define their individual legacies. While one contributed to India’s democratic institutions, the other remains a controversial figure in the country’s political landscape.
The debate around their influence continues, with Hamid Ansari being scrutinized for his political views and Mukhtar Ansari being pursued for his criminal activities. Regardless of where one stands, their stories remain crucial in understanding the dynamics of politics, crime, and public perception in India.
ये दोनों ही कट्टरवादी मुस्लिन थे और अन्य धर्म के लोगों का सदैव अहित किया-उनके प्राण लेने की सीमा तक, औरयदि नहीं किया तो उनका अपने आपराधिक और काले कारनामों में यथासंभव उपयोग किया है। इन दोनों अंसारियों ने देश हित में कभी एक भी काम नहीं किया है।